There are some things that simply taste better in Cornwall, such as ripe berries that have caught the best of the summer sun, or a traditional pasty after a bracing walk. Then, there’s the pinnacle of English treats: a freshly baked scone, sliced in half and filled with strawberry jam and a generous helping of clotted cream.
An authentic Cornish cream tea is one of those simple pleasures that feels right at home in the county.
© Candocreative / Shutterstock.com
Perhaps that’s why it feels so perfectly suited to a place where the pace of life seems to slow down as soon as you cross the River Tamar. As you take the first bite, the last remnants of everyday stress simply melt away.
History of cream tea
Tea drinking became fashionable in Britain during the 17th century, helped enormously by Catherine of Braganza, the Portuguese wife of Charles II. Already accustomed to drinking tea, she is widely credited with helping to make it fashionable among the British aristocracy.
By the early 18th century, tea was becoming increasingly familiar in Britain, although it remained an expensive luxury. Thomas Twining opened his famous tea shop on the Strand in London in 1706, helping to establish the beverage as a familiar part of British life.
Then came afternoon tea. The story most often told begins in 1840 with Anna, Duchess of Bedford, who reportedly felt hungry during the long stretch between lunch and evening dinner. She began drinking tea and eating bread, butter and other small snacks during the afternoon. Before long, this became a fashionable social occasion, with cake, sandwiches, scones, jam and cream being associated with the ritual.
Birth of a West Country tradition
By the middle of the 19th century, tourism was starting to transform Cornwall. The arrival and expansion of the railways made the region considerably easier to reach, bringing visitors south in search of fresh air, seaside holidays and a change of scenery. In 1852, the West Cornwall Railway began operating passenger services between Penzance and Redruth, extending to Truro a year later.
Hotels, guesthouses, farmhouses and tearooms soon had plenty of hungry visitors to feed. Comforting, relatively simple and made using ingredients the West Country had in abundance, cream teas fitted beautifully into this new holiday culture. Dairy farming was established across the region, and clotted cream had become a much-loved local speciality.
An older story involves Tavistock Abbey in Devon, where workers were said to have dined on bread served with cream and preserves as far back as the 11th century. Whether this can truly be considered the first cream tea is another matter, but it offers an intriguing glimpse into the region’s long association with simple, comforting food.
Cornwall, meanwhile, developed its own dining traditions. Interestingly, Cornish splits (slightly sweetened bread rolls) were once served with cream and jam. The modern scone eventually became the familiar foundation for a cream tea and was firmly embraced into the county’s culinary identity.
Cream teas are for everyone!
Not always the everyday indulgence we enjoy today, cream teas emerged from fashionable and wealthy households, until tourists could sample them too in the Victorian and Edwardian eras. A gentle afternoon spent sitting somewhere scenic and enjoying a sweet snack became part of the pleasure of taking a holiday. This idea has never disappeared.
Today, a Cornish staycation might include a morning walk along a cliff path or an afternoon exploring a harbour. There’s plenty of time to explore at your own pace, stop for a cream tea and enjoy a leisurely afternoon before heading back to wherever you’re staying.
Cream or jam first on scones?
Now we come to the important bit. The question of what comes first has been responsible for plenty of passionate discussions. In Cornwall, the answer is clear: jam first, followed by a generous dollop of clotted cream. The Devon method reverses the order, putting cream on the scone first and jam on top.
There’s no need for raised voices across the Tamar, of course, as this is a friendly rivalry. The Cornish method has a pleasing logic, keeping the jam beneath the cream rather than asking you to balance a soft topping while spreading.
How did Queen Elizabeth II enjoy hers?
If you ever wondered how Queen Elizabeth II ate her cream tea, the answer adds an interesting twist for royal watchers. Former royal chef Darren McGrady said the late Queen’s scones followed the same order favoured in Cornwall at Buckingham Palace Garden parties. In other words, Her Majesty was aligned with the Cornish method. Of course, royal kitchens have their own traditions, and cream tea etiquette isn’t governed by constitutional law!
King Charles III has added another chapter to the royal scone story. He has been seen taking a keen interest in the great debate, even questioning the arrangement of a boy’s scone at the Royal Cornwall Show in 2018! On noticing the youngster eating a scone covered with cream and then jam, he quipped, “Have you got that the right way round?”
The pleasure of a proper Cornish cream tea
Perhaps one reason a cream tea has endured is because it has never been about the scone alone. It’s also about the setting. It’s the clink of a teaspoon against a China cup, the comforting warmth of the teapot, the sound of gulls and the sea lashing against the coast beyond the tearoom window. It’s a walk along the seafront, followed by the discovery you’ve somehow worked up an appetite for two scones rather than one.
For visitors exploring Cornwall, a cream tea can become one of those small holiday moments that you remember long after you’ve arrived home. Despite the changes in life around it, this simple tradition remains reassuringly familiar.
From its long history to the friendly rivalry over how it should be served, the Cornish cream tea has earned its place as one of Cornwall’s best-loved culinary traditions. Simple, unmistakably local and still enjoyed by generations of visitors and residents alike, it’s a tradition that shows no sign of disappearing.